Compiled Top 20 Thread! CURRENT

Harbinger
1. Human Blackguard
2. Drow Cleric of Lolth
3. Mind Flayer
4. Tiefling Captain
5. Elf Pyromancer
6. Cleric of Gruumsh
7. Cleric of Order
8. Hound Archon
9. Wraith
10. Sword of Heironeous
11. Orc Warrior
12. Umber Hulk
13. Nebin, Gnome Illusionist
14. Bearded Devil
15. Displacer Beast
16. Devis, Half-Elf Bard
17. Arcane Archer
18. Cleric of Corellon Larethian
19. Large Fire Elemental
20. Vadania, Half-Elf Druid

Dragoneye

1. Large Red Dragon
2. Eye of Gruumsh
3. Black Dragon
4. Purple Dragon Knight
5. Thayan Knight
6. Orc Druid
7. Cleric of Nerull
8. Gold Champion
9. Ogre Ravager
10. Dwarven Defender
11. Brass Dragon
12. Red Samurai
13. Drow Wizard
14. Urthok the Vicious
15. Blue Wyrmling
16. Silver Sorcerer
17. Goblin Skirmisher
18. Cleric of Moradin
19. Bladesinger
20. Halfling Outrider

Archfiends
1. Champion of Eilistraee
2. Large Silver Dragon
3. Aspect of Lolth
4. Red Wizard
5. Aspect of Orcus
6. Orc Champion
7. Gauth
8. Aspect of Bane
9. Graycloak Ranger
10. Snig the Axe
11. Erinyes
12. Vampire Aristocrat
13. Aspect of Demogorgon
14. Moon Elf Fighter
15. Cursed Spirit
16. Evermeet Wizard
17. Vrock
18. Bone Devil
19. Cleric of Lathander
20. Mialee, Elf Wizard

Giants of Legend

1. Mordenkainen the Mage
2. Lord Soth
3. Rakshasa
4. King Snurre
5. Frost Giant
6. Lich Necromancer
7. Drider Sorcerer
8. Fire Giant
9. Lareth the Beautiful
10. Inspiring Marshall
11. Stone Golem
12. Aramil, Adventurer
13. Eberk, Adventurer
14. Blue Slaad
15. Young Master
16. Regdar, Adventurer
17. Half-Giant Psychic Warrior
18. Githyanki Renegade
19. Red Wyrmling
20. Standardbearer

Aberrations

1. Ryld Argith
2. Frenzied Berserker
3. Mind Flayer Telepath
4. Yuan-Ti Abomination
5. Crow Shaman
6. Half-Elf Bow Initiate
7. Green Dragon
8. Alusair Obarskyr
9. Warforged Hero
10. Kobold Sorcerer
11. Wyvern
12. Hook Horror
13. Valenar Commander
14. Adventuring Wizard
15. Cleric of St. Cuthbert
16. Sahuagin Ranger
17. Dragon Samurai
18. Chuul
19. Ice Troll
20. Orc Sergeant

Angelfire

1. Archmage
2. Mounted Paladin
3. Ogre Mage
4. Hezrou
5. Efreeti
6. Justice Archon
7. Ghaele Eladrin
8. Chraal
9. Cleric of Dol Arrah
10. Mina, Dark Cleric
11. Sword Archon
12. Large Copper Dragon
13. Ulmo Lightbringer
14. Steel Predator
15. Barbed Devil
16. Orc Wolf Shaman
17. Trumpet Archon
18. Celestial Pegasus
19. Chain Devil
20. Wand Expert

Underdark

1. Balor
2. Elminster of Shadowdale
3. Iron Golem
4. Helmed Horror
5. Artemis Entreri
6. Marut
7. Aspect of Kord
8. Duergar Champion
9. Death Slaad
10. Guenhwyvar
11. Mounted Drow Patrol
12. Justicator
13. Battle Plate Marshal
14. Xendrik Champion
15. Large Deep Dragon
16. Drow Arachnomancer
17. Medium Silver Dragon
18. Half-Fiend Ogre
19. Slayer of Domiel
20. Githzerai Monk

War Drums

1. Shuluth, Archvillain
2. Warduke
3. Aspect of Hextor
4. Orc Wardrummer
5. King Obould Many-Arrows
6. Aspect of Moradin
7. Chimera
8. Hill Giant Barbarian
9. Arcane Ballista
10. War Troll
11. Zakya Rakshasa
12. Large Bronze Dragon
13. Warforged Barbarian
14. Sacred Watcher
15. Snig, Worg Rider
16. Dragon Totem Hero
17. Inspired Lieutenant
18. Tiefling Blademaster
19. Warpriest of Moradin
20. Dragonne

War of the Dragon Queen

1. Large Green Dragon
2. Blackguard on Nightmare
3. Cadaver Collector
4. Tordek, Dwarf Champion
5. Storm Archer
6. Large Fang Dragon
7. Griffon Cavalry
8. Meepo, Dragonlord
9. Golden Protector
10. Warden of the Wood
11. Bonded Fire Summoner
12. Yuan-Ti Halfblood Sorcerer
13. Stirge
14. Slaughterstone Eviscerator
15. Small Fire Elemental
16. Redspawn Firebelcher
17. Dragonborn Fighter
18. Small Black Dragon
19. War Weaver
20. Clawfoot Rider

Will add as later sets' top 20s get announced.

NOTE: I pretty much gave up here, as I don't like the polls, I don't like the format, etc. If somebody wants to pick this thread up and finish it, sure. If not, it will remain dead due to my own personal disinterest, and the apparent lack of everyone else's after hearing they will all be restatted anyway.

Bump for the new all-stars. Nearly done!

No, it's not a huge issue now, but I would like to see what 60 come out faster than the rest. Now I'm not as mad stuff like the orc warrior made it in in previous voting.